How Dr. Malone faced Blumenthal’s smear and Fauci’s fear

Senator Richard Blumenthal’s scurrilous attack on Dr. Robert Malone is no laughing matter, even though it literally is predicated on a laughing matter. From his perch in Washington, Blumenthal once lied about serving in Vietnam: stolen valor. In August, he reached for lies again—weaponizing a shooting at the CDC to smear Malone – an attempt to deter RFK, Jr., via his choice as chairman of the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices, ACIP. A meme posted that morning, satire and nothing more, was anachronistically twisted into incitement. Malone called it “thought pre-crime.” It was the heckler’s veto in its purest form—speech turned into crime because a politician didn’t like the joke. Blumenthal, Harvard magna cum laude — yet (sadly) reality-dullard (or bought and paid for), can’t or won’t distinguish satire from threat.

That episode was only the opening act. In our second segment, Malone and I turned to the deeper sickness in medicine. He described medical societies as cabals, largely subsidized by pharmaceutical money. Doctors, I noted, “school like fish”: not from evidence, but from pressure.

Hormone replacement therapy as example: in the 1990s it was widely accepted. Then a single surgeon, Susan Love, proclaimed it dangerous, outside her specialty, but amplified nonetheless. The Women’s Health Initiative followed with stacked data. Suddenly, HRT was discredited, despite strong evidence of its benefits when prescribed correctly. “They cherry-pick the endpoints and they don’t look at the holistic picture,” Malone said.

That same selective vision defined COVID. Public health measured narrow endpoints—case counts, transmission curves—while ignoring collateral damage: mental health, overdoses, lost livelihoods. “Epidemiology is fundamentally socialist. It is based on the utilitarian logic that the ends justify the means… but they’re optimizing the greatest good based on a limited number of parameters.” Harms that didn’t meet statistical thresholds were written out of existence. “If a phenomenon, let’s say a vaccine harm, doesn’t meet statistical significance, then from the CDC standpoint, it doesn’t exist.”

This narrowing of vision was not just sloppy. It gutted ethics. Informed consent, once the cornerstone of medicine, was treated as expendable. “There’s a growing belief that patients don’t have the right to informed consent,” Malone said. The physician-patient relationship was replaced by checklists, protocols, and dictates from statisticians with little biology and no patients of their own. “The MPH is basically a two- to three-year statistics course. It doesn’t require you to take any biology. And yet they’re anointed as the new gurus of public health.” Their conclusions trickled down to insurers and medical organizations, producing “protocol-driven medicine” that could be run by AI. Independent doctors were left “barking mad out of frustration because nothing that they’re doing makes sense.”

Which brought us to the “original sin” of modern vaccine policy: the 1986 National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act. By shielding manufacturers from liability, Congress created the incentive structure we live with today. Fear campaigns became funding machines. Fauci perfected the pitch. Whether the disease was Zika, Bird Flu, West Nile, or COVID, the script was the same: hype the threat, stir Congress, then collect the money. “His pitch was: ‘I will cure your pain (your pain being your constituency’s fear). All it’s going to take is fill in the blank—five hundred million, two billion, whatever the number is.”

I know Zika well—I wrote in 2022 that “The Zika vaccine never was; its experimental trial should never be.” There was no sustained epidemic, no proven link between the virus and microcephaly, and no justification for the billions siphoned away from real research. Yet Fauci redirected funds from cancer and diabetes into Zika, long after the panic had passed. Malone agreed the campaign was a misattribution and a warning. “In no case [with these repetitive viral panics], with the questionable exception of the mRNA vaccine, is there an actual vaccine. But it doesn’t matter. Because the money flows. There’s no accountability. There’s never any kind of post-outbreak assessment by Congress. And the band plays on.”

That is the system: bureaucracies fueled by fear, enthroned as infallible, unchallenged by accountability. It rewards incompetence so long as the dollars keep flowing. Malone put it bluntly: “It’s not good governance to have this entrenched bureaucracy that believes itself to be infallible.” And yet that is where medicine now stands.

Blumenthal’s attack on Malone was not just politics—it was emblematic. A man who once fabricated his own record now smears a physician who earned his standing the hard way: in research, and in speaking truth against power. That is the contrast: stolen valor versus earned valor. And if we can no longer tell the difference, we will keep paying the price—in policy, in medicine, and in trust.

Join us at 5 pm ET weekdays on America Out Loud Talk Radio. Listen on iHeart Radio, our world-class media player, or our free apps on Apple, Android, or Alexa. Discover all the episodes on podcast networks, i.e., Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Pandora, TuneIn, Stitcher, and iHeart. You’ll find them the day after they air on talk radio, available on podcast. Extraordinary voices for extraordinary times.